By James Folk, principal software engineer and founder of NJLIGames Ltd (building software on Long Island since 2015).
1. It is not built for a phone
Most of the people who find your business are looking at it on a phone, not a laptop. If your site still requires pinching and zooming to read a sentence, or the menu button does not work with a thumb, you are not losing a few visitors to that, you are losing most of them, since a phone is the default way anyone finds you now.
2. It loads slowly
A visitor decides whether to wait or leave in about the time it takes to read this sentence. Every extra second of load time costs real visitors, and if you run paid ads to the site, it also costs you money directly: Google charges more per click for a landing page that loads slowly, because it knows the visitor is more likely to bounce.
3. You cannot update it yourself
If changing a price, adding a photo, or fixing a typo means calling a developer who has not answered in months, or paying by the hour for a five minute change, that is not a website, it is a liability with a login screen. A site you cannot touch is a site that quietly goes stale, one small omission at a time, until none of it is current.
4. It does not look like the business you run today
A site built five or ten years ago was designed around the design trends, the services, and sometimes the business name of that era. Visitors size up a business by its website in seconds, the same way they size up a storefront, and a dated site quietly tells them the business itself might be dated too, even when nothing could be further from the truth.
5. It does not show up when someone searches for you
An old site was often built before Google cared about mobile speed, clean code, or the structured data that helps a search engine understand what a page is actually about. If a competitor with a newer site consistently outranks you for searches you should win, the site itself, not your reputation, is usually the reason.
6. Nobody currently knows how to get into it
Ask yourself honestly: do you know who has the login to your hosting account, your domain registrar, and your website's admin panel? For businesses that inherited a site from a previous owner, a relative, or a freelancer who has since moved on, the honest answer is often no. That is not a cosmetic problem. It means you do not fully control an asset with your business name on it.
7. It describes a business you no longer run
This one hides in plain sight, because the site still loads fine. But if the services list is missing what you actually sell now, the photos are of a team that has since changed, or the pricing or service area on the page is simply wrong, the site is not outdated in how it looks, it is outdated in what it says, and a visitor has no way to know which parts to trust.
What to check before you commit to a full rebuild
Not every one of these needs a ground-up redesign. A single broken form or one stale phone number is a fix, not a project. The pattern worth acting on is three or more signs at once, since at that point the underlying problem is usually the platform itself, not any one page on it.
How do I know if I need a redesign or just a few fixes?
If the problem is one or two things, like a broken contact form or an outdated phone number, that is a fix, not a redesign. If you recognize three or more of the signs above, the site as a whole is working against you, and a redesign is the faster and cheaper path.
How much does a website redesign cost?
At NJLIGames a redesign is $0 down and $175 a month, the same package as a new site, since a redesign is built the same way. You keep your domain, your old site stays live until the new one launches, and you approve the design before we build anything. If you would rather own it outright, it is $3,800 once, plus $25 a month for hosting.
Will I lose my Google rankings if I redesign my website?
Not if it is done correctly. The risk is real when a redesign changes URLs without redirects, drops page titles and descriptions, or removes content Google had already indexed. A redesign done right keeps every URL working, carries the old content forward, and often improves rankings, since Google rewards the faster loads and mobile-friendly markup a rebuild brings.
How long does a redesign take?
Most redesigns take 2 to 4 weeks from kickoff to launch. Your old site stays live the entire time, so there is no downtime and no rush to approve something you are not sure about.
Related reading: what a redesign actually costs and how it works, what a website costs on Long Island, and Wix versus hiring a web designer.
Get A Free Design Preview
See what a redesign would actually look like before you commit to anything. You pay nothing unless you love it.
Get A Free Design Preview